Apologetics: Matthew 28:16-17
Contents
Text
Problem
Did the disciples first see the resurrected Jesus in Galilee or Jerusalem? If Jerusalem, why did Jesus tell Mary to tell the disciples to meet him in Galilee? Does this contradict Jesus' command to stay in Jerusalem until the Holy Spirit was given?
Resolution
A quick reading of the Luke passage makes it seem as if Jesus appeared to the disciples just as they received the report of his appearing on the road to Emmaus, then spoke to them for a while, led them out to Bethany and ascended to heaven. However, Luke is compressing multiple events together (see the article from Tekton below for more on this). As Luke records in his second book, Acts, Jesus appeared to the disciples several times over a forty-day period (Acts 1:3). The meeting in Galilee that Matthew refers to probably occurred after Jesus first met the disciples in Jerusalem, i.e. Luke 24:44 and/or 24:45 refer to separate events from Jesus' appearance in 24:36-43. Also, John records a meeting in Galilee that took place after Jesus' appearing in Jerusalem (John 21:1).
The article below from Apologetics Press hypothesizes that Jesus had to meet the disciples in Jerusalem first since they didn't believe the reports from the women who had seen Jesus.
Jesus' instruction to remain in Jerusalem was probably given closer to the time of his ascension and after the meetings in Galilee (Acts 1:4-5 is consistent with this).
External links
- "Meet Me In Galilee" - Apologetics Press
- Did They Tarry in the City? - Tekton Apologetics Ministry
Return to Apologetics -> Scripture index -> Matthew
Return to Apologetics: Mark
Return to Apologetics: Luke
Return to Apologetics: John
Note to users: The wiki is currently operating in safe mode. Editing is limited to users with certain privileges in order to deal with spam. You can create a new user account, and confirm your email ID in order to obtain ability to edit pages. Learn how to be an editor or sysop at WikiChristian.
Sponsors: WikiChristian is supported by W8MD's NYC weight loss, sleep and medical aesthetic centers.
